Movie Review “Battlefield Earth”
May 5th, 2011This week we sit Keith down to check out the infamous “Battlefield Earth“. Will he survive this scientology mess? Read on to find out!
As a “B” movie/bad-movie geek, I have a masochistic urge to seek out any and all films that have been tagged as the “Worst Ever” to watch and find out for myself if they’re really as bad as everyone says. In the case of 2000’s legendary flop “Battlefield Earth,” the critics and public were most definitely right on the money.
First, some background. I resisted checking out “Battlefield Earth” for over a decade till I recently picked up the DVD at a store that was going out of business. With the clearing-house prices going on there at the time, it cost me less than a buck. I figured at that price, even if the movie totally sucked, I could use the disc as a beer coaster and still feel like I got my money’s worth. A week or two later I sat down to watch and was so bored that I said “Screw this” and bailed out on it after about forty minutes, which is something I rarely, if EVER, do with a movie. My film-goer’s O.C.D. will not allow me to leave a movie unfinished, however, so I knew that I would have to go back to the film and see it in its entirety at some point.
Flash forward a few months. I’m home sick from work with an absolutely brutal stomach virus and praying for death anyway, so I figure since I’m already miserable, I may as well give “Battlefield Earth” another whirl. I did make it through the entire film this time, mainly due to the fact that I was too tired and weak to reach for the “stop” button on my DVD player. So how bad was “Battlefield Earth?” Absolutely wretched! If this movie supposedly cost upwards of $50 million, why does everything look like a cheap SyFy Channel Original? The story is ludicrous, the acting is terrible, sets and costumes are painful to the eyes, and the pacing is absolutely slug-like. The only member of the cast who looks like he’s having any fun at all is John Travolta (this film was supposedly a dream project of his for several decades; I wonder how he looks back on it now), as the alien bad guy “Terl,” who resembles a Klingon with boogers permanently hanging from his nose. We’re supposed to swallow the idea that after an alien invasion of Earth by a race of bureaucrats called the Psychlos, humanity has spent the last millennium narrowly avoiding extinction by reverting back into tribes of nomadic, moronic cavemen. Thankfully one of said humans, Jonny “Goodboy” Tyler (Barry Pepper in a career killing performance) believes there must be more to life than this, and leaves his tribe to see what’s out there in the big wide world. Naturally, he gets captured by the Psychlos within five minutes, and after spending a good chunk of the film getting thrown into a variety of cells, having a bunch of slow-motion fist fights with alien guards and other human captives, and going “ARRRRRRRGH!” a lot, Jonny’s lucky enough to get chosen by Travolta’s character for a special slave-labor chore which necessitates being educated by one of the aliens’ “Intelligence Machines.” Unfortunately for the bad guys, this gives Jonny the smarts to not only understand things like complex machinery and mathematics, but also the ability to teach these concepts to the other captive humans and inspire them to fight. Thus, in the last quarter of the film the rag tag band of Earthlings strike back against the Psychlos using long-forgotten, leftover human weaponry like Harrier jets, machine guns, and rocket launchers which amazingly still work just fine even though they’ve been sitting around for a thousand years. Oh yeah, suuuuuure. I take back what I said about the SyFy Channel earlier — even they would’ve passed on this idea as “too ridiculous.” The ending of the film (which, as I understand, only covers about half of L. Ron Hubbard’s original novel) leaves things open for a sequel, which thankfully will never come to pass.
So in the end, was “Battlefield Earth” the “worst movie ever,” as so many have claimed? No. I can say with some authority that there is much, MUCH worse out there. Was it the worst thing I’ve seen in a while? Oh yes, definitely. Do I ever want to sit through it again? Hell, no! This “Battlefield” is worth a look only for students of truly bad cinema, Travolta completists, members of L. Ron Hubbard’s Church of Scientology (though I bet even they’d find it a tough go) or the terminally out-to-lunch. Looks like I’ve got myself a new beer coaster.
Brought to you by Keith Abt, the Dollar DVD Guy. He suffers through these movies so YOU don’t have to!
















